Since 1989, Gammon & Associates has devoted its practice to representing community associations. Designed to be a self-contained, efficient legal agent for community associations, the firm offers its clients a results-driven legal fee billing approach. Instead of unlimited billable hours, Gammon & Associates typically doesnt collect until our clients do. The result is a cash-flow-positive legal strategy for our clients who avoid the risk of traditional law firm billing models. Hows that for a cost-effective legal solution?

Sunday, April 27, 2008

If you're going to buy Foreclosure Properties, don't forget that there's a RIGHT OF REDEMPTION

I'm writing this article because of a recent run-in with a prospector of real estate after this prospector purchased a property at a local county constable's sale. This property belonged to a homeowner who had fallen several years behind on the maintenance assessments to the community association, and simply could not come up with the necessary funds to rescue the home from the clutches of foreclosure.

Now I am not decrying the business of buying and selling foreclosure properties -- this is America after all, and the foreclosure mechanism is just another animal by which wealth is redistributed to those who can afford it from those who cannot. It really makes for a rather efficient transfer of property in most cases; however, Texas Property Code section 209.001, et seq., does recognize a homeowner's absolute right to redeem such a foreclosed property within 180 days after the foreclosure sale commenced if a property owner's association lien is the instrument being foreclosed upon. It's called the Texas Residential Property Owners Protection Act and it is very much alive and well.

In fact, Section 209.011 of the Texas Property Code states that "[t]o redeem property purchased at the foreclosure sale by a person other than the property owners association, the owner must pay to the purchaser of the property:

(a) any assessments levied against the property by the association after the date of the foreclosure sale and paid by the purchaser;
(b) the purchase price paid by the purchaser at the foreclosure sale;
(c) the amount of the deed recording fee;
(d) the amount paid by the purchaser as ad valorem taxes, penalties, and interest on the property after the date of foreclosure sale; and
(e) taxable costs incurred in a proceeding brought under Subsection (a)."

Tex. Prop. Code § 209.011(e)(2). Thus, if a homeowner has the funds necessary to comply with those sums listed in the above provision, and that homeowner tenders said amounts to the purchaser of the foreclosed property, then the purchaser must allow the homeowner to redeem the property. It's that simple.

I have attended some constable's foreclosure sales in the past and I cannot tell you how many uninformed, ill-advised, uninitiated prospectors I've seen purchase property after property without having the faintest clue that the property is subject to purchase money liens, government tax liens, etc. These buyers lack the understanding of priority lien concepts, assumption of mortgages, and other pitfalls that come along with foreclosure sale prospecting. Instead, these people buy the property in hopes of turning a quick buck, ignorant of the laws under which they purchase, then trample the rights of those people who would attempt to redeem when such a situation becomes tenable. Now back to the original prospector I was speaking about.

In this case, the homeowner obtained the necessary amounts to redeem under section 209.011 of the Texas Property Code, tried to redeem the property from the purchaser, but the purchaser refused the redemption offer. The purchaser demanded all sorts of outlandish sums for property management, attorney's fees, and "research costs" for prospecting the property. It was obvious that the prospector was conducting a "money grab" -- attempting to attach all manner of ethereal charges to the property -- so that the profit margins could be artificially boosted on the purchase if the homeowner ever tried to redeem. The homeowner, distraught and not knowing where to turn to, actually asked the community association for help.

The homeowner may have the last laugh here because the right to redeem goes hand in hand with the foreclosure sale and is not to be ignored if such a remedy is sought. Texas Property Code section 209.011(f) states that “[i]f a purchaser fails to comply with this section, the lot owner may file a cause of action against the purchaser and may recover reasonable attorney’s fees from the purchaser.” So now, the homeowner may seek recovery of all attorney's fees incurred in the fight to redeem the property. The law is clear in this case, the homeowner can redeem if it complies with the statutory provisions of the Texas Residential Property Owners Protection Act. All the homeowner needs to do is tender those amounts listed under Section 209.011. In turn , the purchaser of the property must tender a deed back to the homeowner or suffer civil penalty.

Ultimately, I hope that the purchaser at least learns a valuable lesson from all of this legal wrangling: the homeowner's right of redemption is absolute under the Texas Property Code when a property owner's association forecloses its lien. Don't be an uninformed prospector; instead know the law regarding foreclosure sales before you buy.